Food for thought

img_vert_mcdougalls2

I’ve read a lot about Dr John McDougall. He interests me a lot, aside from the fact that his profile shots with Mrs McDougall belong hung above the fireplace of a woodlands house, or in a 1970’s winter fashion catalogue.

He runs a 10 day live in program in California aiming to reverse chronic disease. Amongst other things, McDougall advocates that nutrition is one of the most effective ways to prevent and treat heart disease (and cops it from cardiovascular surgeons who are losing their bypass patients to him).  His successful ‘Star McDougallers’ are real life endorsements for the removal of animal products in the diets of CHD patients. The whole testimonial thing is a bit creepy but that’s probably just an American thing. The style of filming, set design and editing is a little bit too “Hi, I’m Troy McClure“. Get RID of the red velvet curtain in the background. 

In my opinion the people who would benefit from this kind of dietary change are the most unlikely to go to a health retreat. While I like his concept, the marketing seems wrong to me. The market segment that needs this info the most are low income earners, with busy lifestyles and poor nutritional knowledge. They are not going to spend 10 days in a health retreat. They need this packaged in a way that makes sense and has value to them.  Processed, prepackaged food is expensive. Meat and animal products are expensive. Grains and legumes are cheap.  Fresh fruit and vegetables are cheap. 

Having heart disease is expensive.

Not having heart disease is cheap. 

There are a lot of people that can be reached if a product or service breaks convention with its advertising. The success of the Skinny Bitch series can be attributed to:

  • the lack of the word “Vegan” in the title
  • the chick lit style cover
  • a paparazzi photo of Victoria Beckham emerging from a shop clutching the book

If the authors of the Skinny Bitch series had titled their books “Vegan Fare” and used cover art of an kitchen bench laden with fruits and vegetables they would have significantly reduced their audience. I think the McDougall program is doing great things with their diet vs drugs philosophy (peas vs pills, oatmeal vs obesity, cabbage vs CABG), but they haven’t broken convention enough with the way they spread their message. It’s possible that their methods of communication mean that they’re only preaching to the converted (and the willing to be converted). 

I’d like to see the MacDougalls cut loose a little. 

Advertisements

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

3 Responses to “Food for thought”

  1. pranabchatterjee Says:

    This indeed is a good one! What does the evidence base in the medical research world say? Nutrition, I guess, has long been implicated as a causal factor in CHD, so why not try tobring it around as a remedial measure.

    Good work!

    Keep blonding it up!

    And puhleeeeeze get the emai sign up…

    Yeah, I know I am lazy…

    😉

  2. C Says:

    The evidence base is predominantly from T. Colin Campbell’s epidemiological study The China Study. The book is a good read – here’s one of his lectures:
    http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1308977765978236346

    I’ve tried setting up the email sign up and got really confused but managed to set up feedburner:
    feed://feeds2.feedburner.com/medicallyblonde

    WordPress doesn’t seem to want to let me add the chicklet? argh!

  3. Pranab Chatterjee Says:

    C,

    You cannot add the Form for signing up for Feedburner email alerts here on WP, but you can add up the lin to sig up for email subscription like I have dne on my blog)!

    Why not try that out!

    And thanks for the link!

    Cheers!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: